Direct-Acting Surge Relief Valves

Direct-Acting Surge Relief Valves protect municipal water systems from destructive pressure surges by automatically opening when system pressure exceeds a preset threshold, typically 10-20% above normal operating pressure. These spring-loaded valves use direct pressure sensing to actuate without external controls, opening within milliseconds to discharge excess pressure through atmospheric venting or return lines. Performance is typically rated for surge pressures up to 250-400 psi depending on valve size and spring configuration. The primary limitation is their binary operation - they're either fully closed or discharging, making them unsuitable for systems requiring modulated pressure control or where continuous small pressure fluctuations could cause frequent cycling and premature wear.

• High Service Pump Discharge Lines (2-24" diameter): Installed 50-100 feet downstream of pump stations, these valves protect against water hammer from pump trips or power failures. Connected between main discharge header and atmosphere or surge tank, they open at 15-25 psi above normal operating pressure. Selected for rapid response time (50-200 milliseconds) compared to pilot-operated alternatives.
• Transmission Main Isolation Points: Located at high elevation points in 12-36" transmission mains, typically every 2-5 miles. Connected via 4-8" branch lines to atmosphere or surge vessels. Chosen for their simplicity and reliability in remote locations where pilot systems might freeze or fail.
• Filter Backwash Systems: Positioned on 6-16" backwash supply lines to prevent vacuum conditions during rapid valve closures. Installed upstream of backwash control valves, venting to atmosphere. Selected for their ability to admit air during negative pressure events while sealing against normal operating pressures of 30-60 psi.

Daily Operations: Operators typically monitor valve position through SCADA indicators during normal rounds. No routine adjustments required during stable operations. Visual inspection for proper seating and absence of continuous discharge during monthly facility walks. Position should remain closed under normal system pressures.

​

Maintenance: Annual inspection includes diaphragm condition, spring calibration verification, and seat cleaning. Requires confined space entry procedures if accessing surge tanks. Basic mechanical skills sufficient for external adjustments, but internal repairs need manufacturer-trained technicians. Spring replacement intervals typically 5-8 years depending on cycling frequency.

​

Troubleshooting: Common failure modes include diaphragm fatigue (chattering during operation), improper seating (continuous weeping), and spring degradation (delayed response). Warning signs include pressure anomalies during pump starts, unusual noise from valve locations, and SCADA alarms. Typical service life 15-20 years with proper maintenance, though diaphragms may require replacement every 7-10 years in high-cycling applications.

• Spring-Loaded Diaphragm Assembly: Typically 4-20" diameter neoprene or EPDM diaphragm with stainless steel spring stack. Spring force calibrated for specific cracking pressures (10-150 psi range). Selection based on required pressure differential and expected surge magnitude.
• Valve Body and Seat: Cast iron or ductile iron construction for 4-24" sizes, with bronze or stainless steel seating surfaces. Body rated for 150-250 psi working pressure. Flanged connections per AWWA C110 standards.
• Adjustable Spring Mechanism: External adjustment capability allows field tuning of opening pressure ±10%. Typically includes tamper-resistant hardware and position indicators.
• Air Release/Vacuum Breaking Ports: Sized orifices (1-8" diameter) for controlled air admission/release rates. Include insect screens and freeze protection features.
• Position Indicators: External visual or electronic feedback systems showing valve position, essential for remote monitoring in SCADA systems.

• Pressure Parameters: Set pressure: 10-300 psi (typically 75-150 psi for municipal distribution), Overpressure allowance: 10% maximum above set point per AWWA C510, Blowdown: 2-7% below set pressure for proper reseating, Inlet pressure rating: 150-600 psi ANSI class
• Flow Capacity: Sizing coefficient (Cv): 0.1-50 for 1"-8" valves, Relief capacity: 50-5,000 gpm depending on valve size and pressure differential, Response time: <0.1 seconds for direct-acting operation
• Physical Specifications: Valve sizes: 1"-12" (most municipal applications use 2"-6"), Body materials: Ductile iron, bronze, or stainless steel per AWWA C509, Seat materials: EPDM, Buna-N, or Viton depending on water quality, Spring materials: 316 stainless steel for corrosion resistance
• Performance Requirements: Accuracy: ±2% of set pressure under steady-state conditions, Temperature range: 32-180°F for potable water applications, Minimum upstream pressure: 1.2x set pressure for proper operation

• What is the required relief capacity and at what pressure differential? Engineers must calculate maximum surge flow based on system hydraulics and pump characteristics. Undersizing by 20% can result in system overpressure and pipe failure. Requires detailed transient analysis and pump runout curves.
• Should the valve discharge to atmosphere or back to the system? Atmospheric discharge wastes treated water but ensures complete pressure relief. System return (via accumulator tanks) conserves water but requires 15-20 psi backpressure consideration in sizing calculations. Wrong choice affects both water loss economics and relief performance.
• What set pressure provides optimal protection without nuisance operation? Set pressure must be 10-15 psi above normal operating pressure but below pipe pressure rating. Too low causes frequent cycling and seat wear. Too high risks pipe failure during surge events. Requires accurate system pressure mapping.
• Is pilot-operated control needed for large diameter applications? Direct-acting valves become impractical above 6" due to spring force requirements. Pilot systems add complexity but enable larger capacities with precise control.

• Division 40-48: Process Integration
• Primary: 40 05 23 - Control Valves
• Secondary: 40 05 13 - Basic Process Instrumentation (for pilot-operated systems)
• Note: Some specifications place surge relief under Division 33 (Utilities) when integrated with distribution system design.

• Material/Equipment Verification: Verify bronze/stainless trim for potable service, Confirm NSF-61 certification for drinking water contact, Check pressure rating matches system design (typically 150-300 psi)
• Installation Requirements: Minimum 10D upstream, 5D downstream straight pipe, Bypass piping for maintenance access, Concrete thrust blocks for larger sizes
• Field Challenges: Pilot line routing conflicts with other utilities, Access for adjustment in confined spaces
• Coordination Issues: SCADA integration for position indication, Lead times: 12-16 weeks for standard models

• Cla-Val: Model 50-01 automatic control valve with surge anticipation - widely specified in 4"-24" municipal applications
• Watts: Model 25AUB surge anticipating valve, proven in 100+ municipal installations
• Singer Valve: Model 106-PRS pressure reducing/surge relief valve, popular for smaller systems
• KSB: BOAX-TI series, gaining traction in larger municipal projects (12"-36")

• Surge tanks/standpipes: Better for severe transients, 2-3x higher capital cost but lower maintenance
• Variable frequency drives (VFDs): Prevent surge at source, preferred for new pump stations, similar installed cost
• Bladder surge suppressors: Compact alternative for space-constrained sites, 30-40% higher cost than direct-acting valves but faster response time

Size conservatively - undersized valves create water hammer instead of preventing it. Establish relationships with local manufacturer reps early; they provide field calibration support that's invaluable during commissioning. Specify factory pre-setting when possible to reduce field adjustment time. Consider valve exercising programs; stuck valves are common failure points. Budget 15-20% above base valve cost for proper installation accessories and controls integration.