Pressure and Differential Pressure Switches

Pressure and differential pressure switches provide automated monitoring and control of system pressures in municipal water and wastewater treatment plants. These electromechanical devices use diaphragm or bellows mechanisms to actuate electrical contacts when preset pressure thresholds are reached, triggering pump starts/stops, alarms, or process control actions. Typical municipal applications include pump station control (5-150 psi operating ranges), filter backwash initiation (differential pressures of 8-15 psi across media), and low-pressure protection for membrane systems. The primary trade-off is between sensitivity and reliability - more sensitive switches provide tighter control but are prone to nuisance trips from pressure transients common in municipal systems.

• Filter Backwash Systems: Differential pressure switches monitor headloss across rapid sand or anthracite filters (typically 2-8 feet), triggering automatic backwash cycles when differential reaches 6-8 feet of water column. Connected upstream of filter inlet and downstream of underdrain system. Selected for reliable automation in 2-20 MGD plants where manual monitoring isn't practical.
• Pump Station Protection: Pressure switches protect high-service pumps by detecting low suction pressure (typically 10-15 psig minimum) or excessive discharge pressure (150-200 psig maximum). Installed on pump suction/discharge piping with isolation valves. Critical for preventing cavitation damage and pipe failures in distribution systems.
• Chemical Feed Systems: Pressure switches interlock chemical pumps with main process flow, ensuring polymer or chlorine injection only occurs when water flows through treatment trains. Monitors pipeline pressure (20-80 psig range) to confirm adequate flow conditions before chemical addition.
• Membrane System Monitoring: Differential pressure switches track fouling across MF/UF membranes, initiating cleaning cycles when transmembrane pressure exceeds 15-25 psi differential. Essential for maintaining flux rates and preventing irreversible membrane damage in 1-10 MGD membrane plants.

Daily Operations: Operators verify switch status lights on SCADA systems and check local pressure gauges during rounds. Typical monitoring includes filter differential pressure readings (2-6 feet normal range) and pump discharge pressures (60-120 psig typical). No routine adjustments required during normal operation, but operators log pressure trends to predict maintenance needs.

​

Maintenance: Quarterly calibration checks using portable pressure calibrator, comparing switch actuation points to design setpoints (±5% tolerance typical). Semi-annual cleaning of pressure sensing lines prevents plugging from biofilm or sediment. PPE includes safety glasses and nitrile gloves when handling process connections. Requires instrument technician skills for calibration and electrical troubleshooting.

• Pressure Sensing Element: Diaphragm or bourdon tube converts pressure to mechanical movement. Stainless steel or EPDM diaphragms handle 0-300 psig municipal ranges. Selection based on media compatibility and pressure range - diaphragms for low pressure (<150 psig), bourdon tubes for higher pressures.
• Switch Mechanism: SPDT or DPDT snap-action switches rated 10-15 amps at 120/240V. Microswitches provide precise actuation points (±2% accuracy typical). Gold-plated contacts resist corrosion in humid plant environments.
• Adjustment Mechanism: Threaded adjustment screw sets actuation point within instrument range. Typical municipal ranges: 5-50 psig, 10-150 psig, or 25-300 psig. External adjustment allows field calibration without disassembly.
• Process Connection: 1/4" or 1/2" NPT threaded connections with 316 SS wetted parts. Includes isolation valve and pressure snubber for pulsating applications. Connection size matches plant piping standards and maintenance accessibility requirements.
• Enclosure: NEMA 4X polycarbonate or aluminum housing protects electronics from washdown and chemicals. IP65/67 rating standard for outdoor installations. Conduit entries accommodate 1/2" or 3/4" electrical connections per NEC requirements.

• Pressure Range: Standard municipal applications typically require 0-100 psi for water systems and 0-30 psi for wastewater applications. High-service pumps may need switches rated to 300 psi.
• Differential Pressure Range: Filter monitoring requires 0-50 psi differential capability. Membrane systems need 0-100 psi differential switches for cross-membrane pressure monitoring.
• Accuracy: ±1-2% full scale for critical applications like high-service pump protection. ±3-5% acceptable for alarm-only functions such as filter differential monitoring.
• Deadband/Hysteresis: 2-10% of setpoint to prevent chattering. Pump control switches typically use 5-15 psi deadband for start/stop functions.
• Response Time: <1 second for pump protection applications. Up to 5 seconds acceptable for non-critical alarms.
• Process Temperature: -40°F to 180°F covers most municipal applications. Digester gas applications may require ratings to 200°F.
• Wetted Materials: 316 SS standard for potable water. Hastelloy C-276 for chlorine gas service. PTFE diaphragms for aggressive chemical applications.
• Electrical Ratings: NEMA 4X minimum for outdoor installations. Intrinsically safe ratings required for methane environments in digesters and lift stations.

• What pressure range and accuracy class is required for the specific application? Pump protection switches need ±1% accuracy with 0-300 psi range, while filter differential alarms can use ±3% accuracy with 0-50 psi range. Wrong selection leads to nuisance trips or inadequate protection. Need: system operating pressures, required protection setpoints, and criticality of application.
• Should you specify electromechanical or electronic switches? Electromechanical switches (Barksdale, Ashcroft) cost $200-400 but offer proven reliability in harsh environments. Electronic switches (Rosemount, Endress+Hauser) cost $800-1,500 but provide better accuracy and remote monitoring capability. Wrong choice affects maintenance requirements and integration complexity. Need: control system compatibility, accuracy requirements, and maintenance philosophy.
• What deadband setting prevents pump cycling while ensuring adequate system pressure? Typical high-service pumps use 10-15 psi deadband (start at 45 psi, stop at 60 psi). Insufficient deadband causes excessive cycling and motor damage. Excessive deadband creates pressure swings affecting system performance. Need: pump curves, system demand patterns, and acceptable pressure variation.
• Are explosion-proof or intrinsically safe ratings required? Methane environments in digesters, lift stations, and biogas systems require Class I, Division 1 ratings. Standard NEMA 4X switches fail catastrophically in these environments. Need: hazardous area classification drawings and gas detection system design.

• Division 40 - Process Integration
• Section 40 05 19 - Instrumentation and Control for Water Treatment Equipment
• Primary section for pressure switches integrated with treatment processes. Also applicable: Section 33 09 53

• Material/Equipment Verification: Verify wetted materials compatibility with process fluid, Confirm electrical ratings match control panel specifications, Check temperature ratings for outdoor installations
• Installation Requirements: Provide isolation valves for maintenance access, Install pressure snubbers for pulsating applications, Ensure proper electrical conduit sealing for wet locations
• Field Challenges: Vibration from nearby pumps affects mechanical switch life, Impulse line plugging in dirty water applications, Condensation in electrical enclosures
• Coordination Issues: Coordinate switch settings with PLC programming, Lead times typically 2-4 weeks for standard models

• Ashcroft - Model 1009 pressure switches common in chemical feed systems and pump controls, widely specified in municipal applications.
• Dwyer - Series 1950 differential pressure switches popular for filter monitoring, reliable performers in water plants nationwide.
• SOR - Model 4NN mechanical switches preferred for critical pump protection applications, robust construction for harsh environments.
• Barksdale - Series 96211 switches used extensively for air scour and backwash systems in municipal facilities.

• Electronic pressure transmitters with relay outputs provide better accuracy and diagnostics but cost 3-4x more than mechanical switches. Preferred for critical applications requiring remote monitoring.
• Flow switches can substitute for differential pressure switches in some pump protection applications, typically 20% higher cost but eliminate impulse line maintenance.
• Level switches replace pressure switches for tank applications, similar cost but eliminate pressure calculation requirements and provide more reliable operation in municipal storage tanks.

Install bypass valves around differential pressure switches on filter applications - allows continued operation during switch maintenance. Specify stainless steel wetted parts even for potable water to prevent corrosion issues long-term. Build relationships with local Ashcroft and Dwyer distributors for faster delivery and technical support. Consider buying spare switches for critical applications like high service pump protection - switch replacement is faster than repair during emergencies.