Surge Relief Valves for Wastewater Service

Surge relief valves protect wastewater pumping systems from destructive pressure transients caused by pump starts, stops, and power failures. These spring-loaded or pilot-operated valves automatically open when pressure exceeds a preset threshold, diverting flow to relieve dangerous pressure spikes that can rupture pipelines and damage equipment. Typical municipal installations handle pressure surges up to 150% of normal operating pressure within 0.5 seconds of activation. The primary trade-off is balancing quick response times against nuisance opening during normal pressure fluctuations, requiring precise pressure setting calibration for each specific pumping application.

• Raw Sewage Pump Stations (2-25 MGD): Installed downstream of centrifugal pumps on 12-36" force mains to prevent water hammer during pump trips. Connected between discharge header and wet well return line. Selected for rapid response to pressure spikes exceeding 150 psi, protecting expensive pumping equipment and concrete structures

• Effluent Pump Stations: Positioned on 8-24" discharge lines from final clarifiers to prevent backflow surge when downstream pumps cycle. Typically set 10-15 psi above normal operating pressure. Critical for protecting biological treatment processes from hydraulic shock

• Sludge Transfer Lines: Installed on 6-12" lines between thickeners and digesters to handle pressure transients from progressive cavity pumps. Selected for solids-handling capability and corrosion resistance in high-sulfide environments

• Recycle Water Systems: Applied on 4-16" lines serving filter backwash and plant water systems, preventing pressure spikes that could damage membranes or media beds

Daily Operations: Operators monitor pressure gauges upstream and downstream of valves during routine rounds. Check pilot system air pressure (80-100 psi typical) and verify sensing line isolation valves remain open. Record pressure readings and note any unusual cycling or chattering sounds indicating potential problems.

​

Maintenance: Quarterly inspection of pilot system components and annual disassembly for cleaning. Requires confined space entry permits when accessing wet wells. Standard PPE includes respirator, fall protection, and gas monitoring. Maintenance staff need basic pneumatic/hydraulic system knowledge and valve repair experience.

​

Troubleshooting: Common failures include pilot system air leaks causing slow response, sensing line plugging from grease buildup, and disc sticking from debris accumulation. Warning signs include pressure gauge fluctuations, audible air leaks, or failure to relieve during pump shutdowns. Typical service life 15-20 years with proper maintenance.

• Pilot Control System: Hydraulic or pneumatic actuator responds to upstream pressure changes within 0.1-0.5 seconds. Typically bronze or stainless construction for 6-36" valve sizes. Selection based on required response time and operating pressure range (50-300 psi)

• Main Valve Body: Cast iron or ductile iron construction with rubber-lined disc for wastewater service. Sizes range 4-36" with flanged connections. Epoxy coating standard for corrosion protection in municipal applications

• Pressure Sensing Line: 1/2" stainless steel tubing connects upstream pressure to pilot valve. Must be sized to prevent plugging while maintaining rapid response. Includes isolation valve and pressure gauge for field testing

• Discharge Piping Connection: Typically returns flow to upstream wet well or equalization basin. Sized 1.5-2x valve port diameter to prevent cavitation during relief events

• Flow Parameters: Relief flow capacity: 10-2,500 GPM for 0.5-50 MGD plants; Pipeline velocity: 3-12 fps in gravity systems, up to 15 fps in force mains; Maximum allowable pressure: 150-300 PSI depending on pipeline class

• Pressure Settings: Relief pressure setting: 125-250 PSI (typically 10-25 PSI above normal operating pressure); Reseat pressure: 85-95% of relief pressure setting; Pressure surge magnitude: 50-200 PSI above static pressure

• Performance Specifications: Opening time: 0.1-0.5 seconds for surge conditions; Closing time: 2-10 seconds to prevent water hammer; Accuracy: ±3% of set pressure under steady-state conditions; Temperature range: 32-140°F for typical municipal service

• Physical Constraints: Valve sizes: 2"-24" for municipal wastewater applications; Minimum upstream straight pipe: 5-10 pipe diameters; Discharge piping: sized for 150% of relief capacity at 5-10 fps velocity; Materials: ductile iron or stainless steel bodies, EPDM/Buna-N elastomers for wastewater compatibility

• What is the maximum allowable pressure surge magnitude and duration? Threshold: >150 PSI surge or >2-second duration requires active relief. Consequences: Undersized valves allow pipe failure; oversized valves cause excessive cycling and premature wear. Need: Transient analysis data, pipe pressure ratings, and pump/valve operating characteristics

• Should the valve discharge to atmosphere or a closed system? Threshold: Discharge >500 GPM typically requires closed system return. Consequences: Atmospheric discharge creates regulatory violations and flooding; closed systems add complexity and potential backpressure issues. Need: Site drainage capacity, environmental permits, and downstream system hydraulics

• What control method provides optimal response time? Threshold: Pressure rise rates >50 PSI/second require pilot-operated valves. Consequences: Direct-acting valves may be too slow; pilot systems add failure points but provide faster response. Need: Surge analysis showing pressure rise rates and acceptable response times

• How should the valve integrate with existing SCADA systems? Threshold: Plants >5 MGD typically require remote monitoring capability. Consequences: No monitoring leads to undetected failures; over-instrumentation increases maintenance costs. Need: SCADA architecture, communication protocols, and maintenance staffing levels

• Primary: 40 05 23 - Wastewater Pumps - Surge relief valves are typically specified with pump stations

• Secondary: 40 05 13 - Common Motor Requirements for Wastewater Treatment Equipment - For electrically-operated pilot systems and controls

• Material/Equipment Verification: Verify 316SS internals for wastewater service; Confirm AWWA C512 compliance; Check pressure rating matches system design (typically 150-300 PSI)

• Installation Requirements: Require concrete thrust blocks at direction changes; Specify 5D straight pipe upstream/downstream; Include isolation valves and drain connections

• Field Challenges: Access for maintenance in wet wells; Interference with existing piping/electrical

• Coordination Issues: Coordinate with structural for vault sizing; Lead times: 12-16 weeks for standard municipal sizes

• Val-Matic - Model 207 Surge Relief Valve, widely specified in municipal projects with proven 20+ year service life

• APCO - Model 143 Combination Air/Vacuum valve with surge relief capability, popular for smaller plants under 5 MGD

• Crispin - Model SRV series, gaining traction in Canadian markets

• ARI - Model D-025 surge relief valves, established in larger municipal installations exceeding 25 MGD capacity

• Air/Vacuum Valves with surge relief - 30% less expensive, suitable for systems under 2 MGD with moderate surge potential

• Hydropneumatic tanks - Better for frequent cycling, 2-3x higher capital cost but lower maintenance

• Variable frequency drives on pumps - Eliminates surge source entirely, most expensive option ($15,000-50,000 per pump) but provides operational flexibility and energy savings

Establish direct relationships with manufacturer technical support - they provide invaluable troubleshooting during commissioning. Size discharge piping one size larger than calculated minimum to prevent backpressure issues during surge events. Consider specifying pilot-operated models for systems over 30" diameter to reduce maintenance frequency. Negotiate factory testing for critical applications - adds $2,000-5,000 but prevents costly field modifications.